Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Golf and Spa

Explore Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Golf and Spa
7.8
Pleasant
From 716 reviews
Cleanliness

8.2

Room Comfort

8.4

Location

8.8

Service and Facilites

8.2

Traveller Reviews Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Golf and Spa

Number of reviews per page
20
40
Top reviews
Lynne
8.0
/10
Reviewed 14 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

The hotel was reasonable priced and set in stunning grounds. My room was clean and comfortable. Nice to be able to use the pool at no extra cost. I would consider staying here again and would recommend.
Andrew
icon-
6.0
/10
Reviewed 16 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Decent facilities but it's starting to look really tired in places, particularly bathrooms
Andrew
icon-
6.0
/10
Reviewed 17 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Just okay and nothing more. Staff are pleasant but restaurant service is below par and the rooms are looking dated.
Andrew
6.0
/10
Reviewed 17 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Ok. Rooms looking tired and most have been in need of some repair over the last few stays
Samantha
6.0
/10
Reviewed 18 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

The room was suitable and golf surroundings very pretty. However we had a broken toilet seat. I did find the food expensive for the quality that was served. Breakfast was also average, and seemed disorganised.
Andrew
icon-Friends and Family Family
Friends and Family Family
10.0
/10
Reviewed 18 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Clean, comfy room
Andrew
icon-Business
Business
6.0
/10
Reviewed 19 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Staff on reception are really good and the rooms are fine. Service at breakfast is terrible. I waited close to 5 minutes for someone to come out of the kitchen to find me a table, then 15 minutes for a bowl of porridge that was barely lukewarm when it arrived.
Michelle
icon-Leisure with Partner
Leisure with Partner
10.0
/10
Reviewed 20 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Clean room, staff was great.
Andrew
icon-Business
Business
6.0
/10
Reviewed 20 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Room was superficially fine but a little dirty in places (black mould in the shower). Service at breakfast was slow and quality of the food no better than average. Surroundings of the hotel are great for a walk in the evening and exercise facilities better than most hotels.
Andrew
icon-Business
Business
8.0
/10
Reviewed 20 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

OK, and reasonable value for money. Nice to have gym and pool available for use.
Phillip
8.0
/10
Reviewed 21 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Overall a great stay, just one niggle but they said they’d sort
Anthony
icon-
8.0
/10
Reviewed 24 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Staff very friendly and helpful especially in Reception Restaurant food was Verg good ,well cooked and tasteful I belief freshly cooked Will stay again in the future ,
ryan
8.0
/10
Reviewed 26 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Yes, very nice stay.
KAREN
icon-with Partner
with Partner
10.0
/10
Reviewed 27 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

The bathroom had a gas smell in the night and the toilet in room 215 was extremely difficult to flush . Tv needs a manual and couldn’t get standard channel on but room and view was wonderful. Staff short in breakfast area . Had to wait to get sat down . N still havnt got out toast . Food was lovely when we got it though .
Catherine
icon-Leisure Family
Leisure Family
8.0
/10
Reviewed 28 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

The room was large and clean with a super king size bed. The staff were extremely friendly and obviously enjoyed their job. I also like the beautiful well kept grounds and easy parking.
Tim
icon-Leisure with Partner
Leisure with Partner
8.0
/10
Reviewed 28 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Lovely room, very clean. Friendly staff and nice setting between 2 golf courses. Nice spa on site too. Sometimes a bit of a wait for service in the restaurant and bar, staff seem to be spread a bit thinly maybe due to being out of season?
Jon-Paul
icon-Business
Business
4.0
/10
Reviewed 31 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Shower had black mould growing in there Staff was excellent and helpful Breakfast was small
David
icon-Friends and Family Family
Friends and Family Family
4.0
/10
Reviewed 31 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

For a 4 star hotel we expected a higher standard. When entering the room it was lovely however the bathroom really let us down. There was mold, thick limescale coming out of the taps. It didn't look clean. The restaurant is extremely overpriced considering the amount of money being spent for the room and the spa, £8 for garlic butter i think is disgusting oh also a service change just to top it all off. The Spa is really where we enjoyed ourselves. The staff are extremely lovely and helpful. We only had half a day but it was well worth it.
Read More
Lucile
icon-Business with Pet
Business with Pet
10.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Very friendly staff even when arriving late. Accomodating re dog
Andrew
icon-Leisure with Friends
Leisure with Friends
2.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Room and bathroom wasn't clean, limescale hair and a broken shower.
Number of reviews per page
20
40