Overall Ratings & Reviews The Jane Hotel

The 5th floor hallway smells strongly of urine.

I love the Jane for its old school charm Small rooms and shared shower not for everyone but great value for those that can

Should have a different name, since it's no longer the fun place it used to be three years ago. Now it's just an overpriced glorified hostel.

We checked in and checked out 15 minutes later. There were pictures of lounge spaces that showcased a charming environment. Where as the rooms are isolated and small as is, the common spaces were where we had planned to post up with laptops, engage in conversations etc. when we arrived, we learned EVERYTHING was under construction. There was not a single place besides your tiney room to exist. We never would have booked here had we known. I had paid in advance through Expedia, so there was no way to get our money back. Booked 2 rooms and left 15 minutes later.

The neighborhood was amazing. Loved how many great restaurants were around. It was a shame that a lot of the common areas were permanently closed at The Jane. We were not aware of this when we booked and they were actually the main reason we chose to stay here. The promotional pictures on The Jane's website and social media still heavily feature these areas that dont exist. Staff were wonderful though and the shared washrooms were always clean.

The Jane is nice if careworn. It's under new management and the entrance, once unique, is at motel standard and in the basement. There's no longer rooftop access, lounge and cafe attached and though near dining, it's not the same. There is a feeling now that hotel guests are an afterthought; no slight to the doorman and front desk staff, but that vibe remains

Located right between the West Village and Chelsea, it is an amazing area to call home. The staff at The Jane Hotel were all very friendly and helpful. We were able to keep our luggage at the front desk after check out, to allow us an easier last day in the city. The room, while very small, was pleasant and clean. It utilized an energy saving stick key fob for entry and electricity, and the bathroom was clean. The shower wasn’t quite hot enough, and the hallway to reach the bathroom was cluttered with boxes, but the hotel and restaurant next door share an elevator, and I understood it. Mostly, I loved the location and the staff were friendly, and I felt safe and clean, so I’d highly recommend it to anyone who wants to visit NYC. It’s only a few minutes walk to Starbucks Reserve Roastery, which is a must-see. And Little Island park, and the High Line. Just a great area.

Not great

Lovely management and clean facility. Unfortunately we could not complete our stay due to the construction! Hope to catch you once it’s completed.

I really loved the hotel, the rooms are a tad small but it was very comfy

Not the most comfortable bed I’ve ever slept in, but very affordable for a private room. Shared bathroom was clean and not very busy. Area feels safe and has plenty of bars and restaurants within walking distance. 14-ish minute walk from the nearest train station.

I have stayed at this hotel 2x because of its price and location, but the first time my sheets had not been replaced, I slept in them and left with a staph infection that lasted for 2 weeks. This past time I paid extra attention to cleanliness and washing my hands after touching things, the subway, etc. I left with the flu. I have been to NYC many many times and ridden the subway many many times, the only times I remember leaving the city sick had the common denominator of the Jane Hotel. Very disappointing because it has a very cool vibe, but they need to properly disinfect the rooms and clean the sheets with an anti-bacterial detergent. Disappointed.

The Jane was a unique experience. I never been to motel like that for lack of better words. But it served the purpose and if needed I would do it again.

The room had Jo bathroom and it was only one sofa with towels as cover sheets , Horrible customer service bad very bad

A nice little neighborhood and the subway is nearby.

Great accommodations

I decided to stay at the Jane hotel due to its history with the Titanic and early 20th century NYC. But when I arrived the historic lobby is not accessible (being turned into a private club) and the basement checkin desk is revamped modern but still under renovation. Room was as described slept well but honestly it just felt like a low end hotel without the history.

Undergoing construction currently, bathrooms were not kept very clean. Beds were small, could not fit and uncomfortable.

The Jane is under renovation so only single rooms are available. As a solo traveler, that was fine with me. The rooms are tiny, accommodating a twin bed & not much else. The bathroom is down the hall. Everything as clean & neat. It was quiet. You can’t adjust the temperature of your room. It’s winter & the heat is on. There is a fan but even with it in the room is too warm. The neighborhood seems. Overall, this is a good hotel.

I love this hotel. I wish there were more amenities like a vending machine and washing but I’m sure they’re working on it. I love the rooms cause I feel like I’m on a ship. Brian at the desk is too cool! 😎 nice guy and a great voice