Overall Ratings & Reviews Commodore Hotel

Awesome old hotel. Love the look and feel. Only (small) issue was it was a little warm in the room but it was worth it. Everything in walking distance. Would stay again. I did reserve a room with private bathroom.

Low cost stay in the heart of Astoria. Dog friendly.

On the third floor and I believe that the AC unit is directly above that room, and every time it would turn on it starteled me awake. The bathroom and shower are shared and i wasn't aware of that until check in. Very uncomfortable process. The shower room and bathroom were clean.

I stayed here 1 night and was really impressed with the room. I had a great sleep . Bed was very comfortable and the room was spacious, clean and cool. Highly recommend this as a place to stay.

Check in and check out were automated, we never saw a staff person the whole time we were there. Felt a bit creepy but ok. We had no problems that required staff assistance but other guests did and were grumpy about it.

Our particular room was a smaller inner room with no real view. Bed was comfortable, but not as good as some better known chains. There is a fan but no AC and our room could have had a small end table for both sides of the bed but it only had a larger end table. Would have liked more hooks too and I think they could stand to put in a bigger tv. I think our TV was maybe 19 inches. Other would have been nicer. No ice machine, no phone, no WiFi but for a short stay it was fine. Separate shared shower and toilet were clean. Hotel has a lot of character for being 100 years old. Loved the lobby and free drip coffee in the restaurant . Also loved the free movie rental and games. Location is untouchable. Parking is street parking. We did have to move the car once but it was a minor inconvenience and expected for the location. Window poses a safety issue as it can open out all the way and no protection for little kids that could fall out and seriously hurt themselves. Would not recommend this hotel for small kids due to falling out window risk. Also not much to protect against sounds from other rooms or outside so hopefully you are not a light sleeper. I would come back here again though because staff was friendly and place is clean and great location and we don’t have small kids.

The Gentleman that checked us in was friendly and helpful. Made us feel welcome

While we love Astoria and the people, the Commodore fell far below our expectations of a reasonably priced place to stay in town. The first night was a Saturday and the room next door was filled with young men yelling and slamming doors at 1 am. I asked them to quiet down and fortunately within about 20 minutes they did. The second night was better as there was quite a bit of vacancy in the building. The shower and bathrooms were good. The room was advertised as having earplugs and a sound machine but neither was in our room on check in and there was no front desk person. The items were given to us for the second night. The earplugs were very old and useless. The sound machine was great. People should know it is like a decent hostel rather than a hotel.

Liked the location and style. Just wished it had a microwave, ice maker, and fridge. Otherwise really nice.

Front desk staff was great - communicated prior to arrival about after hours check in and parking options. He was very friendly upon arrival. It's obviously a pretty old building and certain details reflect that - window gaps/lack of screens, etc. Most things have been updated, but there are a few details that could use a little care. The self serve lobby fridge was nice, but the ice machine being down was a bummer. Bed was comfy, linens were all super clean. The Keurig and electric kettle was a nice bonus. Having Broder connected was great. The addition of the lobby games and records was pretty cool. Would definitely stay again. :)

Great location, friendly staff.. don't stay on the second floor. The walls and the floors are paper thin. We stayed two nights and didn't get much sleep either night. Everyone can hear each other clear as day, the floor above you is going to be extremely loud and creaky, and no one seems to think twice about other people in the building with them. Also, the building is poorly ventilated with no AC. Depending on how picky you are with the temperature of the room you stay in, it might be a no go for that aspect. If you are on the 3rd floor, I imagine the experience is much, much better.

Nice but tired restoration of a classic hotel. Needs; hook, towel bars, new mattresses, pillows, and bedding.

Great location. Nice old town for a weekend getaway. Feels safe.

Nicely upgraded hotel in historic building. Walking distance to stores and boardwalk. Very pleasant checkin and nice jazz music playing in lobby. Room was comfortable with upgraded bathroom and couch/seating area.

Great Memorial Weekend stay. Comfortable and clean. Housekeeping was an issue. Towels, TP, trash, & bedding were not provided. Fresh towels had to be requested. Otherwise, good location, nice adjoining cafe, fantastic lobby perfect for remote work. Parking was easy.

One of the best places ive ever stayed!! Humighly recommended..great communication

Adorable retro hotel, i would recommend you stay here if you love a homey character vibe :) excellent customer service from the staff. worked with us patiently as our travel time was delayed. felt safe and cozy. loved astoria and this hotel is wonderful!!! also the goonies house is only 6 minutes from here!

We had a lovely stay

GREAT FOR SOUND SLEEPERS Our check in process was smooth and friendly. The location of the hotel was also convenient with plenty of street parking in the neighborhood. However, the owners need to be introduced to the wonders of double glazing. Sleeping in was like sleeping in the middle of a street! Mainly because Highway 101 passes right through the middle of town so the hotel is pretty much adjacent to the highway. Given that most semi traffic occurs in the night, it meant we felt and heard trucks all night. If that weren't enough, the floorboards creaked like those on an 18th century schooner. We thought this was perhaps intentional to fit in with the nautical theme of the hotel. I guess the noise issues are not unknown to the management given that they thoughtfully provide earplugs in room. The 'television' was a 14 inch computer monitor hanging off a wall. Guess management needs to be informed about how cheap televisions have gotten. They have a couple of mirrors solidly fastened to the wall facing the bed. We were quite creeped out by this so we tried lifting it a bit to check for cameras but it wouldn't budge. Again ...creepy! The property is a solid 2 star with 3 star pricing. Okay in a pinch, but not so okay if you are envisioning lazy mornings and lying in bed watching the rain.

Great location downtown