Had I never stayed anywhere else in this area I would have rated a 5. The issue is it is comparable in price to Royal Sonesta Yorkville which is a block away. so compared to that hotel I was not as happy. This room was much smaller. Did not have good drawer space to unpack, and had a wardrobe, not an actual closet. Finally, the Sonesta has an outside patio as well as a rooftop patio whereas Kimpton had no outside space. Finally, Proof bar is a lot quieter than the Fortunate Fox restaurant/bar.