The breakfast was good. It was nice to have the option of eating dinner at the hotel. I liked the atmosphere in Livingston. Maybe it's a Scotland thing because I experienced this at another hotel, but the bathtubs are not the safest. If a sign is required in the bathroom to explain to be careful in the bathtub, then maybe that indicates a problem. Most hotels I have stayed in world wide have walk in showers or a low profile bathtub versus the high profile tub that requires careful entry and exit to avoid falling. Just an observation. Overall great place to stay and would visit again in the future. Thanks.