Overall Ratings & Reviews McKays Hotel Bar & Restaurant

Great attentive staff and friendly. Comfortable and clean

Great bar although a tad expensive. Rooms are warm and comfortable. Restaurant is good but can be busy. Staff friendly and helpful. Limited parking at rear. Great position on the main road in the middle of town. Visited a few times and will return.

our room was across the street in the annex of the hotel. so away from the main lobby area. Looked like the annex was being renovated as when you walked in , looked like they were about to put carpeting down. room was on the street - noisy and hot. no fan available and no water in the room except from the faucet.

We stayed in the cottage for one night, and wish we had time for more. Everything was better than we hoped.

Room was clean and comfortable. Large bathroom. Limited parking at hotel. Small insignificant reception area for hotel guests. Surely an establishment of this size could do better? Priority for McKays is obviously food and bar areas which were ok. I would not accept room 102 again due to the constant banging of the door outside that led to an inner corridor. We were awakened at 6:30am each morning when movement around the hotel started and people were moving through door into the corridor. Despite us reporting this to reception, nothing was done. McKay’s asset is its restaurant/bar staff who were excellent.

Great little hotel in Pitlochry. Room was a little on the small side but staff were amazing and bedroom and bathroom were very clean.

Staff were very helpful friendly. Food and drink was good there was somd live music that we enjoyed. The toilet in the bar area smelt disgusting needs a good deep clean. Ross was ok but definitely not 5 star

Nice hotel, clean, great location, food was lovely and friendly staff. The only reason I put 4 was the room was so hot couldn’t sleep

We loved Pitlochry and McKay's and the spaciousness of the cottage. I will say it was very loud at night with people going by and cars and house is very loud when anyone moves around. Ear plugs definitely needed for a good night's sleep.

Great stay. Clean room. Excellent staff

Well worth it ..

Love Pitlochry and McKays is the perfect location.

Lovely room

Comfortable, clean and staff were friendly and helpful.

Good friendly hotel. Centre if Pitlochry. Live music at weekend.

The room was updated and clean. The bed was comfortable. We ate in the restaurant and the food and atmosphere were excellent. We were worried that the live music might be a problem when we were ready to sleep. It wasn’t- we could not heard the bar at all. However, all night a compressor or fan would come on intermittently for about 30 seconds to a minute each time. The longer it lasted the higher pitched it became. The unit was on the roof of the kitchen which was outside our (and other rooms) windows. Very annoying and difficult to sleep. Too bad because we really liked the place otherwise.

The receptionist was not friendly at all couldn’t even manage smile and had very sarcastic answers to question ie is there parking in the back? “ how should. Know I can see back there” not very welcoming!! But the hotel is good and location is good , not very comfortable bed.

Comfortable room. Good choice of dining and reservable well into the evening. Room would have benefitted from more effective blackout as street light outside

Not as expected attick room which was at the end of what could only be described as a Rabbit warren. A new concept to me is they do not make up the room unless you ask no hot water or heating on second night Staff on the bar were very good not so sure about reception. Would not stay again.

Excellent hotel, would recommend, just be wary of service charges on the bill.