Overall Ratings & Reviews The Sunset Montauk

Went stayed there for Honeymoon, was extremely happy. Great people, felt like home, very clean and beds were so comfortable did not want to get out of it ! Will definitely stay again

Love the grounds. Rooms are comfortable and pretty clean.

I liked the modern feel of the room, its cleanliness, and it was very quiet.

Second time to this property within a month.absolutely my fulltime Montauk resort truly amazing staff perfect room common areas. The whole concept of the hotel is super creative and well thought out

Very good hotel, friendly staff, great bedroom, quiet at night. I intent to come back next year.

We would have prefered to have had decaf coffee available and in the room would have been even better.

It was clean and relaxing and Christy was very helpful

Lovely place! Will stay there again. Brittany and Chrissy were fantastic.

Had such a wonderful few days at this charming motel, very cute property with plenty of seating areas on the property. Short walk to beach and restaurants, pool at the sister hotel right across the street was very nice if not a touch freezing cold. Staff were always cheerful, very helpful and kind, especially Brittany who was so sweet and accommodating. We were sad to leave this beautiful part of the world. Hope to come back one day!

Excellent for family get away.

The staff was great. The room was small and outdated. The towels had holes in them and definitely need to be replaced. We tried to enjoy the beautiful outdoor space however there was a rat out there and I am terrified of them that was definitely an u welcome visitor!

We had a great time. It was just what we were looking for. I’m looking forward to my next stay!

Wonderful location. Staff was so friendly and helpful. Awesome rooms and amenities. Quiet and relaxing. Easy walk to the water and Gosmans dock area!

Wonderful location. Staff was so friendly and helpful. Awesome rooms and amenities. Quiet and relaxing. Easy walk to the water and Gosmans dock area!

Quick Ikea Flipped Motel (Great to stay in 2024, won't be after) Very nice ambiance, especially if you have a large group of friends or family staying, it's easy to take over the lawn area (which could be bad or very good) Things I didn't realize that I felt weren't really advertised when I booked: - There is a pool you can use in their sister hotel across the road - They provide beach chairs/beach towels & bicycles - There is a mini beach a minute walk away - They provide beach passes for a majority of the town's beaches (some are excluded) - The place is very tech savy, they text you your room codes. You can also text the front desk with questions/issues which was nice. Advice to guests - Parking is extremely limited (It does state only 1 car per room on website though) - Note that there is just one loud window AC, not central. Advice to property owner: - Add more hooks in the shower to hang wet bathing suits - Install bathroom fans - Provide Tea Kettles/Coffee makers in the rooms (or at least have a few if they are requested) -Staff to wear name tags (hard to know who works there as the employee dress very nicely just like guests) - ADD SHEER CURTAINS TO THE 1st FLOOR ROOMS. We had to choose between privacy or sunshine so the room was always dark as you can see right in. - Spend the few hundred dollars to put side tables near the beds (only one in the center) Interior is an Ikea quick flip which works awesome for now but I give it until the end of the year

This was my first time visiting this hotel. My family and I enjoyed it very much. The place is very clean and the staff are super friendly. I love the various amenities the place has to offer such as outdoor tables, outdoor seatings, outdoor games and grills to barbecue. I also loved that their sister hotel is across the street and therefore we had access to the pool. The beach is close by. Definitely recommend this place for anyone staying at Montauk.

We enjoyed the property with the outside games and the rooms were very clean. Chrissy in reception was so pleasant and the customer service was excellent. I would definitely stay there again.

Great,very helpful and personable staff

Small unit but very clean and pleasant.

The person that checked us in was very nice and the hotel was just perfect for our stay. It was very cute and clean. We loved it