Overall Ratings & Reviews The Edgartown Inn, The Edgartown Collection

I had a wonderful stay (and best night’s sleep ever!) in this beautiful inn. The whole accommodation, from my stunning King Deluxe Balcony Room to the guest lounge and courtyard, was perfect, and all the staff friendly and helpful. A short walk from the bus station, it was a great base from which to enjoy the sights of Edgartown.

Great location, service and property! I would certainly recommend that the hotel offer breakfasts with hot options and larger portions of yogurt and fruit.

Great location and friendly staff

Excellent hotel. Breakfast was a great bonus. Such a cute property.

Beautiful room and great porch with table and comfortable chais

Beautiful hotel and great service!

Neusa was the best Innkeeper ever. She was kind, welcoming, and made us feel like we were long-lost friends. Rooms are clean. Inn is very convenient. And the continental breakfast was nothing short of gourmet. We plan to come again!

Toiletries were not refilled when empty, but room otherwise cleaned well. Wish there were more hot food options, like one per day.

Beautifully-renovated property with excellent amenities and friendly staff. Paid parking and free first-come parking options. Walls are thin so you hear your neighbors, otherwise, wonderful stay.

Had a wonderful stay at The Edgartown Inn. It was a quick work trip. The Inn is well located close to shops and restaurants. It was a great choice!

Very welcoming staff and comfortable stay! Felt right at home as soon as I checked in. The room was clean and the bed was comfortable. Great location, central to everything in town. Will definitely stay again!

Highly recommend. Great location, great room and great staff. Will be back!

2nd stay at a lark hotel and it was a great one. Friendly staff and newly done hotel made it a great stay. We loved the breakfast!!

Alison was very welcoming and all interactions with the staff were positive. The accommodations were perfect and the Inn is located in a prime location for a quick walk to the water or to the shops and restaurants of downtown Edgartown

Absolutely the most beautiful boutique property I have ever stayed at. The staff is phenomenal, welcoming and encompassing the best of Martha’s Vineyard. As a long time visitor I cannot recommend highly enough!!!

Our family had a wonderful stay at The Edgartown Inn! Helpful, attentive staff and the room was perfect! Centrally located within easy walking distance of shops and restaurants. Will definitely be back!

The entire reception staff was marvelously warm and helpful while the property freshly renovated with island crisp/clean decor. The signature chocolate chip cookie to die for at tea time.

Great hotel in a perfect Edgartown location. Very friendly and helpful staff. Like staying at a friend's house. Bring sleep mask if you need it dark to sleep though, bright room.

This was a cool place with comfortable beds and friendly staff. Close to all the shops and cafe/restaurants in Edgartown.

The Edgartown Inn was so nice and quaint and luxury. Rooms were beautiful. Loved the staff and loved the cookies and treats and coffee!!!