Overall Ratings & Reviews Scotia Lodge

They do not have any food service. Their restaurant closed, and they were “temporarily down” for preparation of their room service menu. Many many other complaints but the staff is not one of them. The hotel owners need to update the website and travel listing and stop being dishonest.

This is our second time staying. The staff are incredible, as are the rooms. Make sure to visit Ferndale too! :-)

Beautiful historic lodge, very clean and nice antique decor. Bed was very comfortable. Front desk and housekeeping were friendly and helpful. Convenient location to Avenue of the Giants and hiking trails. Definitely recommend!

A beautiful historic hotel. Huge rooms. Friendly staff in a lovely town

great history here from clawtooth tub to giant ballroom. very quaint

The room was great, loved the decorations and the bathtub! The staff at the front desk and the bar were very nice. Really enjoyed our stay-highly recommend!

Our experience at the Scotia Lodge was wonderful. Beautiful historic property in excellent condition. A perfect location for visiting the wonderful redwoods. We’ll be back!

There are no places to eat on property except for ordering at the front desk, although there are huge areas for dining. There are signs all around the property for the non-existent restaurant. The rooms are cute and cozy but not functional. It has a great feel to it, but I'm trying to understand the vibe of plastic plants all over the rooms (literally 5 of them) but no useful shelving or drawers. The free drinks are mixed up with those for sale. There are lots of sitting areas on the first floor but none are very comfortable. I get mixed messages from this place.

It’s a lovely old hotel that has been partially renovated. It has charm and some old building limitations. Like no elevator and limited water pressure and uneven hot water. But it’s well located on the edge of avenue of the giants and worth it if that’s where you’re going. The restaurant is closed but there are others nearby

According to the website, we were lead to believe there was a restaurant and bar. We were excited to not have to drive anywhere for these accommodations. Everything was closed and there wasn’t anything too close by. It was pretty disappointing

Would have been perfect if the restaurant and bar were open. Nothing available for breakfast other than coffee. Lack of these was offset by a great room rate, but would have paid more to have food available. Overall, it was a beautiful old lodge and I would reccomend them.

They do not have an elevator to accommodate my visually impaired husband, so permitted us to stay in a suite in the lower floor. Very gracious gesture.

The hotel was very clean and the front desk person was very helpful to us during our stay. Do not recommend the food. It is microwaved at best.

Beautiful old historic hotel, that is impeccably maintained.

Clean and vintage

Very nice renovated property, comfey room, great amenities.

Such a lovely place! Everyone was really friendly. Definitely a hidden gem. Can’t wait to return.

Well done renovation, great room, interesting story about the town. A refreshing stop on our journey.

There was an alarm going off close to the hotel but overall is was a very beautiful place.

Nice property, staff were helpful. I had issues with my booking, I booked "pay at property" but Scotia Lodge took the full payment at time of booking. I contacted Hotels.com, they called Scotia Lodge who refused to credit the payment. Also the $30 "resort fee" was strange, not much vslue there.