Quiet neighborhood, clean and well maintained property, responsive management.

Everything we needed. And close to everything. Great communication. We'll come again

As I booked this trip through Expedia I was at first a little confused/misled at what Siesta Key Island Rentals was. Let me be clear in saying that these are not condo rentals or a hotel, these are not all located in the same area nor do they all have the same amenities! With that said the rental we chose was called “the yellow cabin”. And I can say it was worth every penny. We traveled by plane for this vacay which limited what we were able to bring. I was a little worried about missing out on the beach fun or spending a gazillion dollars on things we would essentially have to leave behind. When I tell you this place supplied everything, I mean it! A beach wagon, umbrella, cooler, beach chairs, sand toys, rafts, boogie boards… there was nothing I wanted for during our time on the beach! The location was quiet and while not on the beach it was a short 200ft walk to the sand! The cottage was adorable, and perfect for our family of 4. Walking distance to a mom and pop grocery store and multiple stores/restaurants while still feeling like we were staying in a quiet little neighborhood. From the owner to the property managers, to the maintenance men, everyone we dealt with was polite and accommodating! Can’t wait to stay again! Thank you!

We had a very pleasant experience working with Siesta Key Island Rentals. Communication was smooth and professional from start to finish, making the entire booking process easy and stress-free. The unit itself was perfect—clean, comfortable, and ideally located. We were able to walk to the beach, restaurants, and shops without ever needing a car. Would definitely rent with them again and highly recommend to anyone visiting Siesta Key!

I want use Expedia to select a vacation destination again.

It was an experience I won’t soon forget. 10/10.

Property listing and details very misleading. Property manager/owner very rude and barges into unit unannounced, without even knocking. 3 beds and 2 bedrooms in the unit but owner states property is only for 2 people max occupancy. A/C quit working overnight and left to wait overnight and until next afternoon for repair service to show up. About the only real positive thing here is the location.

Beautifully updated and has everything we needed to enjoy time in the condo and at the beach. Quiet, too, for being so close to the village.

The Mermaid was perfect for us; clean, well equipped, great location to Siesta Key Beach (4-5 minute walk), heated pool, they supply beach chairs - umbrella - beach towels - wagon. It had everything you need. The Siesta Key Island Rental team were outstanding to deal with, from start to finish their communication was perfect. We will be back!

Amazing place! We loved it. Wish we could have stayed longer!

I love this property and people that run it are awesome. Paige you never left me hanging on anything you always answered my questions or problems immediately. Thank You

This place felt like home. It was so clean! I have never felt so comfortable being so far from home. It was a walkable distance to the most beautiful beach and there were shops close by. I would stay here a million times over.

Everything was perfect!! The only thing I had an issue with is I only had salt and pepper to cook with.. So i had to go to the grocery store to buy other basic cooking stuff

The stay was amazinggggg!!!! Me and my family had an amazing time. It had everything we needed and super clean and close to everything. The service was amazing as well. Recommend 💯.

Great vacation stay

This property was so clean. The communication was very good and its close to everything. I will definitely rent this property again. My wife and I loved it.

A nice place near a wonderful beach. Management was very kind to allow us to move in several hours before official check in time. They also provided plenty of beach equipment and a little library. There was only one small thing that was not OK: the washing machine in the garage was leaking all time while we lived there and nobody was going to fix it, however the stream never reached the rooms.

Perfect spot for the summer

Absolutely awesome and so gutted that we didn’t stay for longer! Siesta key is awesome and our wee home was just the best - couldn’t have asked for anything more.

Very clean and convenient. Spotless and comfortable