Location and service is excellent. The rooms are solid +, my complaint is the elevators make a lot of noise at all hours of the day and night. To me it sounded like someone was banging on the pipes intermittently all day. When I complained I was told they were sold out and that I was “noise sensitive”. Idk, maybe I am, but I’ve stayed at hundreds of hotels around the world and never had this issue before.

So friendly and accommodating we loved every minute and we will come back

nice boutique hotel near carnegie hall. friendly staff, clean, close to the park

Great staff, awesome boutique hotel!

Showed up to a confirmed reservation to have no room. Absolutely absurd.

We stayed for one night, but thoroughly enjoyed the entire experience. Our room was on the smallish side, but well appointed the shower was exceptional. The friendliness and helpfulness of the staff was beyond 5-star. We highly recommend a stay at the Carnegie.

I am picking about cleanliness, and this hotel exceeded my expectations.

It’s very small and tucked away. The room was comfortable and there were no issues. The wine and cheese time was nice. It’s very quiet area.

Great place to stay right near Times Square and Central Park. Breakfast was basic but satisfying and the evening wine and cheese hour was awesome. You can get basic snacks juice coffee tea and water 24/7 downstairs. Will stay again if I’m in NYC.

bad experience…

Be back

Small but great place to stay. The staff is very helpful. The location to the Park and other attractions is very good.

Lovely property

Lovely boutique hotel. Close to Central Park and lots of places to visit. The staff were unfailingly courteous, helpful and cheerful. We will definitely stay there again.

Very small, and no many amenities. But, service, people and location amazing

This is a great simple hotel - Nothing fancy but very clean and well appointed - Room was somewhat on the smaller side but very clean and comfortable - Continental breakfast and wine in the eve complentary! Staff were all very friendly and welcoming - If you dont want the hustle, bustle of a big chain hotel, i highly recommend The Carnegie Hotel!

Our stay was ok. Only stayed one night and not there during the days so I cannot really give a full review. The bedrooms are small, not much space for the price. The rooms were clean. Dining area for continental breakfast is small as well. Continental breakfast was average. They did offer snacks throughout the day and wine and cheese in the evenings for those who like that. Location was good,

This establishment offers a remarkably updated experience, from the lobby to the guest rooms. The exceptional staff distinguishes this property from larger hotel chains. The complimentary wine hour from 5 PM to 6 PM is a welcome amenity. However, the breakfast area could benefit from expansion.

Nice location

We had a great 3 night stay at the Carnegie Hotel. The location is perfect for theatre goers and within few blocks to Central Park and Times Square. Hotel staff extremely accommodating and friendly, helpful, nice. Including breakfast and happy hour are wonderful bonuses. The room was great-although small in size had everything you need for a comfortable, pleasant stay. We will stay here again on our next adventure to NYC!