The Caledonian Island Hotel

Explore The Caledonian Island Hotel
7.2
Pleasant
From 396 reviews
Cleanliness

7.2

Room Comfort

7.2

Location

10.0

Service and Facilites

7.6

Traveler Reviews The Caledonian Island Hotel

Number of reviews per page
20
40
Top reviews
Sean
icon-Leisure with Pet
Leisure with Pet
10.0
/10
Reviewed 24 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Mum had a nice stay at this pet friendly hotel, the dog enjoyed his trip, too!
Mark
icon-Leisure with Partner
Leisure with Partner
6.0
/10
Reviewed 25 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

we had a great stay, a couple of gremlins but not serious The room was comfortable but dated Shower pressure was below expectation some Fixtures not operating properly Apart from that it was a beautiful charismatic place with a bit of a ghostly vibe ❤️ Staff were fabulous and efficient no complaints there 👌
laurence
8.0
/10
Reviewed 26 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

I was delighted with my stay. Yet I suggest that it's clearly mentioned to guests, that it's high up a hill. My body has copd lung disease, it would have been good to know about the hill. Best wishes to all of the staff. The wi-fi in room 105 was intermittent
Cynthia
8.0
/10
Reviewed 27 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Steep steps to property entrance and a heavy door to push open. Very dangerous for older people.
Patricia
8.0
/10
Reviewed 28 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Staff very welcoming, breakfast very good apart from burnt toast. Rooms are quite tired. Windows need replacing as ours did not close, so had to change rooms. Bathrooms retiled, but paintwork on doors and skirtings need cleaning and re-painting. Price was reasonable .
Fran
icon-Leisure with Partner
Leisure with Partner
6.0
/10
Reviewed 29 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Only stayed one night.
Stuart
icon-Leisure with Partner
Leisure with Partner
8.0
/10
Reviewed 29 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Our dog was made welcome. Had to change room, due to a maintenance issue. But nothing was too much for the staff. Got a cup of tea each as too early for check-in (bad weather why we were early). Staff were fantastic.
Jasminder
icon-Leisure with Partner
Leisure with Partner
10.0
/10
Reviewed 30 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

No comment
Stephen
10.0
/10
Reviewed 30 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Me and my partner upgraded to a better room but unfortunately we were woken by dogs barking through the night and early hours of Sunday morning, so was not very impressed with that, otherwise the room was nice and clean and comfortable, we had a breakfast which was very nice and a good choice of things to have.
Peter
icon-Friends and Family
Friends and Family
8.0
/10
Reviewed 31 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

All the chairs in the bar and lounge had sides to them not suitable for big people apart from that the hotel was very nice
Alexander
icon-Leisure Family
Leisure Family
6.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Old fashioned but done the job
Andy
icon-Business
Business
8.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Clean room, quiet stay which is what I wanted as it was a work stay
GILLIAN
4.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

There was no information whatsoever in our room i.e. Dining Times or contact numbers . I was taken ill overnight and into the whole of next day , tried to obtain Doctor via 111 but gave up . A member of Cleaning staff , , was very helpful , gave us number for Reception and Ferry Company . Reported to Reception being ill but male person offered no help . I managed to bring forward Ferry to next day hoping I would be able to drive . Luckily I felt able to attempt journey home . We struggled with our cases and discovered a Lift that we had not been told about ! I reported to the female receptionist that we felt neglected and she had an entry on a large notepad recording me being unwell and to check on us . Despite this and also never appearing for breakfast or dinner we had paid for , no one contacted us . Very poor management .
Read More
karen
icon-Leisure Family
Leisure Family
10.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Booked this hotel May stayed here years ago and wanted to take my parents back. It's a little dated but could not fault the breakfast or entertainment. Sally on reception is a credit to the hotel she was so friendly and helpful. Places are walkable about 10-15 mins to the beach and local bars. Would return
ALEX
8.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

The building is a little tired but the room was comfortable and clean. Staff were at all times friendly and helpful and the breakfast buffet was excellent. Parking can be a problem at busy times with only 3 disabled spaces.
Michael
icon-Friends and Family
Friends and Family
8.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Staff have been excellent. Very accommodating, thank you
karen affra
icon-Friends and Family
Friends and Family
6.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

Room was fine. Reception incredibly RUDE and unhelpful. Not a good start to our stay .
Shawn
10.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Hotels.com verified review

What a lovely hotel Staff were all very nice and friendly & helpful Highly recomended
Peter
icon-Leisure
Leisure
10.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Nice grounds and a lovely breakfast, the room was tidied and the coffee milk and sugar replaced. I had a lovely stay and the island has loads of attractions. Cheers
Christine
icon-Leisure Family
Leisure Family
6.0
/10
Reviewed 32 week(s) ago

Expedia Group verified review

Loved the property. Disappointed on returning to room on 2nd day to find it had not been tidied, no clean mugs, no coffee sachets or milk sachets. Asked at reception to be told could have coffee but no milk. Receptionist stated in the middle of something on screen could find some milk in about half an hour and bring to room. When I called at reception there was a note to say back in 10 minutes so obviously wasn’t in the middle of something. It really spoilt our stay
Read More
Number of reviews per page
20
40

Traveloka Korea Ltd. | Business Registration Number: 291-86-03397 | Representative: LOOI YUNG JOSHUA | Address: Room 5008, 5th Floor, 431 Teheran-ro, Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Republic of Korea (Samsung-dong) | Call Center (Mon–Fri, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM GMT+9): +82 70 5234 2354 | Email: cs@traveloka.com | Mail-order Business Registration: No. 2025-SeoulGangnam-02676 | Tourism Business Registration: No. 2025-48
Copyright © 2026 Traveloka. All rights reserved