Overall Ratings & Reviews Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, Ascend Hotel Collection

Wonderful service, large rooms, and a great location! We would definitely stay here again

Needed a rollaway didn’t have. Beds were very uncomfortable and the A/C was terrible so we sweated all night long and it wasn’t even that hot out. Good luck staying at this place in August. It was nice to have Stop and Shop next door.

Clean and centrally located

Our check in was super easy , rooms were super nice and clean .

Wonderful welcoming staff at a clean modern facility. Room was spacious, comfortable and clean. Hotel is conveniently located right along the #1 and #13 bus routes, and there's grocery and dining options a short walk away. We would certainly come back next time we're in the area!

W

Clean and large room

Loved the room and facilities. In house Pub and restaurant were excellent along with all the staff members we met. Location really requires you to have a vehicle on the island but the free easy parking makes it easy if you do. Would definitely stay here agaib.

Large beautiful rooms

Great location!

Only one thing could use better lighting in the bathroom

Upon departing the Martha's Vineyard ferry from Vineyard Haven, we drove less than 15 minutes to the Edgar Hotel. The staff were welcoming, hospitable, and helpful with suggestions for places of interest to visit. The room was new, spacious, clean with a comfortable bed, and was quiet except for the exit door near our room that would slam shut and wake us up at 5:30 AM. Our corner room had many windows that offered natural light, however, we were on the first floor and cars parked outside our window could see in if we had the blinds open. The only thing missing are black out curtains. The shower faucet was difficult to turn off if you have arthritis. These are minor things in comparison to the convenient location next to Stop and Shop market, ample parking, and close proximity to all the shops, restaurants, and beach. We will gladly reserve a room here again next time we visit.

Hotel was clean. Any the restaurant the Town had amazing food and service

Nice and comfortable bed

Great spot in a great town.

Close to where friends were staying.

The lower floor was under construction. That should have been noted prior to booking. However, we really enjoyed our stay and the walk to Edgartown was only a half mile and it was beautiful.

Loved how spacious the room was. Provided everything including fridge and micro. Comfy beds and super clean. Easy parking. Great hotel!

We had high hopes for the Edgar based on the hotel website, but were sorely disappointed. The bed was the most uncomfortable we’ve ever slept in on all of our travels. Our backs were killing us by morning. The bathroom was an odd mix of new and old. The countertop was a beautiful new quartz with tons of room for all of our toiletries. The shower was old and outdated. The ceiling tiles were disgustingly stained. The plugs were so worn that nothing would stay plugged in; I had to dry my hair in the bedroom. The sink stopper didn’t work. The front desk staff weren’t overly friendly. For some reason, the onsite restaurant was not open the night we stayed. We were looking forward to sleeping in, but were awakened before 7am by loud banging and backup horns; it might have been garbage pickup or deliveries at the adjacent grocery store. Note, there is no elevator but we knew that ahead of time. Do yourself a favor and stay elsewhere. The website doesn’t live up to reality.

Entrance room to the hotel was a little bland; otherwise rooms are good. Located 15mn by walk from downtown.