Always a sold stay on Shelter Island

-

Everyone was amazing

we loved it!

Excellent

Chris, the front desk representative, was so helpful. He was kind and willing to help.

Absolutely beautiful! I really hope to be back there again soon!

Wish they had full cable other than that highly recommended

The hotel was very clean , except for two half bottles of soda left in the room refrigerator , the room was so small there wasn't enough room for a chair so other than the bed no place to sit.

Very spacious room, great coffee, there is a pub downstairs

We had a room with an old door adjoining the next room. You could hear right through it like it was made of paper. It was like sharing a room with a stranger. The stranger came back at two in the morning and kept us awake for 3 hours. For the money it hard to believe that they would subject their guests to it.

Fabulous stay .. staff amazing , customer service amazing will def come Back

I was either misquoted a price of $318.27 and was charged $407.05 on my credit, both of which were sent to my email on the Expedia website. As a vonsequence, I am requesting a refund of $88.78 to my credit card. Thank you.

Overall a great experience. My only issue is that we were given room #2 -and while it’s a great room - due to its location on the first floor it can be noisy in the morning. There seems to be a supply closet right be the door and in the morning workers were getting supplies and talking. Also, the way that the room is set up when you open the front door to the room you can see right into the room and directly to the bed. The hotel was amenable in switching rooms for us if we wanted. Anyway, it was a very good experience and we would definitely be back if the opportunity presented itself.

Property was amazing for our stay in Shelter Island

Prefect place for a staycation

Unfortunately did not meet my expectations for $362 a night. Very disappointed. Not even a chest of drawers or stand to hold your bag for your clothing. Nightstands were wood attached to the wall. No TV nor refrigerator. 2 bottles of water on the table but nothing to keep them cold. Locking the door does not seem secure because you can see the light from outside around the door. Parking lot did not exist because they are under construction. I would definitely not recommend this hotel.

Great stay!