Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, Ascend Hotel Collection

Great spot in a great town.

Close to where friends were staying.

The lower floor was under construction. That should have been noted prior to booking. However, we really enjoyed our stay and the walk to Edgartown was only a half mile and it was beautiful.

Loved how spacious the room was. Provided everything including fridge and micro. Comfy beds and super clean. Easy parking. Great hotel!

We had high hopes for the Edgar based on the hotel website, but were sorely disappointed. The bed was the most uncomfortable we’ve ever slept in on all of our travels. Our backs were killing us by morning. The bathroom was an odd mix of new and old. The countertop was a beautiful new quartz with tons of room for all of our toiletries. The shower was old and outdated. The ceiling tiles were disgustingly stained. The plugs were so worn that nothing would stay plugged in; I had to dry my hair in the bedroom. The sink stopper didn’t work. The front desk staff weren’t overly friendly. For some reason, the onsite restaurant was not open the night we stayed. We were looking forward to sleeping in, but were awakened before 7am by loud banging and backup horns; it might have been garbage pickup or deliveries at the adjacent grocery store. Note, there is no elevator but we knew that ahead of time. Do yourself a favor and stay elsewhere. The website doesn’t live up to reality.

Entrance room to the hotel was a little bland; otherwise rooms are good. Located 15mn by walk from downtown.

N/A

Excellent

The staff could not have been nicer, more friendly or helpful. They were the best part of the stay. The rooms are average size, carpets are tired, but baths, bedding all seem new. Having a fridge & microwave is a plus. There’s no housekeeping during your stay unless requested, which would be a problem, but the door to the service closet with towels and supplies was open & we were told to leave dirty/wet towels on the floor and replace fresh towels on our own as needed. The location is excellent, groceries next door, bike rental across the street. 15 min walk into Edgartown. Unlike their sister hotel across the street, there’s no “hang out” space, no front lounge, etc. and frankly the price is insane, albeit competitively priced… but the entire island is crazy expensive. If you’re looking for a clean, decent place w/a fridge that’s well located to town, beaches, and a friendly staff, this is a good place to stay.

Awesome! Clean and staff amazing!

Left early. Lost 500.00. They didn’t care and not even suggest to try and rent he day missed

Property is dated, wall paper torn in places. Carpet is worn in places. What's to like -- lots of parking, near plenty of restaurants and easy to find. Staff was fantastic.

We stayed for 2 nights and the customer service and staff at the desk was excellent. Definitely we recommend this property.

Loved this quiet and clean hotel

Well located

This place would’ve gotten 4-5 stars had it not been for two things. #1 the bathroom sink was clogged. #2 the smart tv had no internet connection. Apparently according to the staff that works there none of the rooms have internet connection going to the tv so despite have chrome cast you can’t stream apps. For a price point that they charge I expect better.

Charming place but we had a leaky air conditioner which dripped water all over our clothes while we were out and ruined a few. The hotel was nice enough to give us another room but just put a damper on a nice vacation. Not having a night manager on duty, we had to wait the whole night without air conditioning.

Location is great!! The staff are fantastic very friendly and helpful. The room nicely decorated and beds very comfortable. Bath has great large container but rather dark lightening. Great hot water & pressure. Tub needed a little TLC. Did have Lysol with me . Told girl at check out . Hopefully will follow up. Right next door to a stop & shop No need to bring a lot as far as snacks.

The staff was very nice. We felt the price was very high given the location and lack of facilities. About a mile walk into town where shops and most restaurants are (few restaurants closer by). Carpets were worn, no daily housekeeping (you can request). If this was on the water, or had a pool or exercise facilities, or closer to downtown, may have changed our opinion slightly.

Not worth the price. Not what I expected out of an Autograph Hotel. Only amenity was the Restaurant which was great. Hotel staff was great but room/hotel nothing special.