Location-wise: good choice. Walking distance to major attractions (Times Sq., theaters, etc). Walking to Central Park took less than 15 min. Staff in lobby was great. Housekeepers are wonderful.
I had two issues while staying here. The first was a double charge. I had made reservations through Expedia and called ahead of time to find out if the property would accept a debit card for incidentals (which they do) and to find out incidentals deposit ($100 since all fees were paid through the Expedia reservation). When I checked in, the representative confirmed all of this, but my card was charged for the full stay, which I only saw when I checked my bank account. When I inquired about it, the same rep said that Expedia never charged me for the reservation. I decided to contact Expedia since I knew they had charged my account. Expedia contacted the property and the manager said he’d reverse the charge. However, the funds would only go back into my bank account in a few days. It was promptly handled on their end, but a major inconvenience.
The second issue was noise. Loud guests throughout the day, but the worse was in the middle of the night — some sort of altercation or argument in the hallway— which woke me up. You can hear conversations through shared walls.
One final note: there was a panel on the bathroom wall under the sink (looked like a plumbing access panel) which was open. I had to pile up tissue boxes to keep it shut to feel safe. Glad it was a short trip.