We came on a 5 day trip to NY and chose the Broome because of location and good reviews. It turned out that location is indeed amazing (right in the center of SoHo) but the hotel was a big miss versus expectations. we were given a room with a very small window facing a courtyard , on the 2nd floor. We had no light at all in the room. The carpets were dirty, in the room and corridor, which for a hotel of this price is simply not acceptable.
The bed sheets were not changed during the whole stay, despite our ask to have them changed). Finally, in the pictures the hotel features a lovely courtyard, with flowers and a private bar. Nothing of that actually was available, given the hotel was renovating. That is fine, but not when you pay $4k for 5 nights stay. It’s simply not worth the money.