The views from the William Vale are absolutely stunning, but the room itself was quite small and the amenities felt a bit basic. However, this seems to be the case with most hotels in New York.

I am very happy

5 stars, impressive experience, very clean and nice view.

Not close to 4-5 start standard. Furnitures/ cabinets were beat up. Old piece rug. Scratched up floors. No evening turn down.

Got a queen bed and paid for a king

It felt like a scam... amenity fees but only so many chairs are available without having to pay, so what is the amenity fee for if you don't get to use the amenities? An upcharge to check into your room early, despite it being available. Rude and helpless staff, freezing pool etc. I've been to a lot of nice hotels and never have I experienced such tactless and shameless behavior/policies.

The area wasn’t my vibe , Manhattan is more my speed .

Fantastic hotel with a great pool and rooms

Had to wait till

The pool was nice but you can only sit in the lounge chairs for 2 hours and then they make you get up. I was told, prior to me booking, that there was a DJ playing the night we stayed that played to 2 am. There was no DJ, so that was disappointing.

Very nice! A bit sterile but nice. Rooms are very nice.

Overall enjoyed our stay. One elevator had sone

Love

Love

Love the staff

Amazing

The hotel itself is Great. The Night clubs around it are Awful For someone like me. In 65 And just wanted a good nights sleep.

I went on a staycation (LI to Brooklyn) and decided to stay here, mainly because they offered balconies with each room at no additional cost. While it’s on the pricier end, I enjoyed my stay. The hotel is beautiful, I felt like I was away on a resort, despite the construction going on outside (regular NY). The food at Westlight was better than expected. I love that guests get to reserve a chair at the pool for free, although a discounted cabana or chaise would be nice as well. I booked parking through an outside app because $50/day is a little steep. Anyway, I would stay here again.

The rooms were clean, staff were friendly. Pool was great

One of the best hotels I've ever stayed at. It was clean and comfortable. Perfect for a stay-cation. Lots of activities on site or close by to keep you entertained. I also enjoyed the food options. I would visit again.