Nice rooms

Return visitor. Great stay.

The location is a bit far from ammenities so need a car to travel back and forth. Its an older Motel, that has been converted to a boutique hotel. Rooms are spacious and comfortable and a great base to hang out. Pool is small but enjoyable and the lawn is great to relax.

Great place it was very clean and rooms are very big the only down side was it says heater pool but it was cold unfortunately especially for Labor day weekend. Otherwise i would go back again.

I loved this hotel. It was cute, quaint and a perfect girls trip stay. Only thing that was amiss was one of the tv remotes wasn’t working but my friend and I discovered that we could use the other remote to control both tvs. It was only just a battery issue with the remote which isn’t a big deal. The rooms and the pool area are so prestine. I wish I had the chance to use the pool but the activities I planned didn’t align with the time.

The place was clean, the staff was friendly.

The hotel is located in a central part of Southampton, with most attractions within 5–10 miles. It’s clean, well-kept, and the room was spacious and well-equipped. Unfortunately, the service—specifically from Joseph—was disappointing. Upon arrival, I was mistaken for a delivery person, which felt dismissive and rude. The check-in process was quick but lacked basic information like Wi-Fi, amenities, or hotel services. I was handed a list of nearby restaurants, as the hotel doesn’t offer on-site dining beyond snacks and drinks. On checkout day, I requested a non-resident beach parking pass. Joseph provided one along with a waiver and a warning about a $500 fee if not returned the same day. He mentioned flooding and that Dune Road might be closed, but didn’t offer to check the status—despite being at a computer. Later, when I asked to return the pass by 2pm, he refused, saying it was due at checkout (11am), contradicting his earlier statement that it was valid “for the day.” He reluctantly extended the deadline to 1pm, which barely allowed time to drive to the beach and enjoy it. There was no flexibility, even though the hotel was quiet and I saw at least 10 unused passes available. Overall, while the hotel itself is fine, the lack of courtesy and accommodation from staff made the experience frustrating and disappointing.

Good hotel. Large comfortable room. Did not stay at hotel much as used mainly as a place to spend the night for day trips to Sag Harbor and Montauck

Great location, hotel room was super roomy for my family if six, beds super comfy and it was quiet at night and slept great! the grounds were well kept and the pool heated. The staff very friendly and helpful. Easy check in and check out! Would definitely stay again.

Excellent

They fined me 250 USD for no reason. They're claiming to have found smoke smell. But that can be from other rooms.

Pleasantly surprised at just how adorable this place was. Also, the room was very large!

Great!!!

Pleasantly surprised

We had an amazing stay at The Bentley Hotel while exploring the beautiful Hamptons! The property is pet-friendly, which was a must for us since our furry friend Roxy loves to travel with us. She absolutely adored the big lawn - it was a godsend for her after being cooped up in our Boston apartment! The rooms were spacious and comfortable, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. The location was also great, allowing us to easily access all the Hamptons has to offer. We can't wait to come back and stay again with Roxy by our side! 10/10 would recommend to anyone looking for a relaxing and pet-friendly getaway."

Loved the decor, record player, pool, cleanliness, location. Very no frills place.

The room was totally renovated and very comfortable, you would not expect this since the outside looks dated but inside is beautiful!

Very clean and nice i fully recommend

The suites were perfect for our group of 4. Comfortable beds and a nice balcony attached to the room.

Great room! Recently updated, clean, and comfortable. Everything felt fresh and well-maintained. Perfect for a relaxing stay.