Overall Ratings & Reviews Blackbeard's Lodge

Quaint but outdated. It would have been nice to have an updated room/space to stay - the a/c was loud, there were no blackout curtains, the fridge was small. I did appreciate the availability of the game room for the hotter days and as a space to gather. The pool was also nice, but parking was a nightmare! We also had two nights where our cart wasn't charging correctly (not one of the Lodge's carts, but the plugs out back were bad), so we were unable to utilize it and it felt like wasted money. I will say the staff were friendly and helpful, and things seemed clean. Overall will likely not be staying here again, but had some nice touches.

A nicely-run and modest hotel somewhat limited by it's older architecture. Our standard room was somewhat small, but well-kept. Super-friendly staff!

Poor customer service, no peace during our stay. Staff neglected to let us know there would be construction on the direct wall outside of our room and bathroom, as well as an a/c unit swap in the middle of the day. Loud hammering, saw noises, nail guns, workers yelling and listening to music from 10am to past 5pm. Property Manager was not very helpful/friendly in the way of making it right. Also would not give me her name when asked. Pool was also pretty dirty.

Clean, cute old school lodge. Has a bed and breakfast feel to it. Would recommend the lodge for sure.

Too many stairs too small room

86yo building with noisy a/c unit and a dehumidifier in the room! No amenities and poor parking. Laughed when asked if we had been here before! Would never go back!

Clean , comfortable and close walking to everything .

Great location and loved the property.

Check-in and out was quick and painless, facilities were warm and inviting, the beds felt great, some stiffness but still soft enough to sink into a little bit. The lodge has some historic feel to it and is pretty much smack dab in the middle of everything, walkable distance to pretty much everything in the town. If I had to pick a gripe it would be parking but everyone knows parking is at a premium on an island, and there is enough available.

Very old, cramp lodging and awfully expensive for what you get.

A lot of steps to room. Walls were very thin and very small refrigerator. Room was clean and had nice staff.

We've stayed at Blackbeard's Lodge a couple of times. We love Ocracoke, and you know staying at Blackbeard's Lodge you are staying in an old-school family-style hotel. However the bathroom of our room really needed some maintenance. It wasn't dirty, it just needed for the shower and tub drain to work better.

it was old and intresting

Loved the place, great folks wolekong the front desk and it was cozy. Walls are a bit thin though, could hear the people next to me snoring.

Blackbeard's is like a bed & breakfast without the breakfast (which is fine, btw). It is an authentic vintage hotel in the heart of Ocracoke, which is exactly what we wanted. I will be visiting again.

The room they gave us was never cleaned from previous people. The second room the wave us was occupied. The final room was one of the cheapest rooms available. In the morning i tried to get a price adjustment for the difference in price and they said there was nothing they could do. Said we had to deal with hotels.com.

The room and location was perfect. The theme is cute too. I recommend booking directly if you have a pet as it’s only specific rooms, Expedia does not know which to mark for pets so this caused issues. There are quite a bit of steps to get to 2nd or 3rd floors.

We loved the deck! The game room looked really nice but we didn’t get a chance to try it out

Ok- a lot of stuff didn’t work including the refrigerator and we had to throw away all our food . A bit far from the city and have to walk on the road because there is no side walks

Wife and I spent the weekend for our 31st Anniversary. Off season and quiet but that’s the way I planned it. Staff was friendly, courteous and efficient. Will be back this summer during the tourist season when the island will be hopping. Recommend Blackbeards Lodge to any and all