Staff is courteous, room is very clean. Shower was so small i was bumping into corners to just turn around- and I am a small woman. Breakfast is absolutely delicious. I do not recommend this hotel to light-mid sleepers. The room is not sound proof at ALL. I could hear every single word the guests in the room next to me were saying and they were speaking at a normal volume. I could hear them turn on the sink or flush the toilet. I am a light sleeper and this went on until 2am and I had to be up at 7am to leave for my flight. I was really upset but didn't complain because I could tell they were not being loud- it is the rooms.

Nice staff and solid breakfast. Beautiful rooms.

It was not bad

Courteous staff. Nice breakfast buffet. Clean room. Great location. Close to the train station and walking distance to all the sites!

The room was very clean. The location was good. The staff were all very friendly and efficient. Breakfast had a nice variety.

Great location and excellent breakfast. However, the room was extremely small — the bathroom had barely enough space to sit. If someone is even slightly big-boned, it would be difficult to fit comfortably in the bathroom, and the shower tub was so tiny there was hardly any room to move.

Not easy to find, but right on the square and part of another hotel (joint). Very short walk from the train station. Staff was very helpful and friendly.

ok

The room was spacious and clean but the shower was super small. My husband who is not large could barely fit in.

Shower cabinet is very small. I had to wash my feet in the bide

Great location, near restaurants, squares, train station and duomo Downsides were how to find as the outside name is hotel garrabadi and not hotel Rosso 23 so spent time walking up and down looking for it. Breakfast was limited and difficult to love around and in crampt space

Excellent location. 5 minute walk from Santa Maria Novella train station. And within fast walk time to Medici Chapels, central market, accademia, Uffizi, and Ponte Vecchio. Quiet hotel. Well appointed room. Small bathroom especially shower. Service was great.

Beautiful hotel with great location. Staff were very kind and accommodating! Room was clean and comfortable, our only complaint was that the lighting was poor (only a few lamps in the bedroom area). The included breakfast was INCREDIBLE! Huge selection and the staff were very friendly. Would definitely stay here again!

Perfect hotel

Awesome hotel!!!!! Strongly recommend!

Cleaning standards are poor

I had a great stay at Hotel 23 Rosso. The location is great and safe while still being close to the train station. The staff was very welcoming and helpful. I had a travel issue with trains and they were very eager to help me figure out alternatives! - much appreciated

Lose to restaurants, shopping, Train Stattion

The lobby is grand, but the room setup is just average. The bathroom, in particular, is extremely small and does not live up to a 4-star standard.

The noise from upstairs coming through the floor is terrible. Sounded like baby elephants dancing in the room above us. One of the tiniest showers I have ever seen with a huge bench in the bathroom. With an internal window all the noise from the downstairs kitchen travels upstairs so u will likely be woken from around 6am. Couldn’t work out why our socks and slippers were going yellow till we realised some sort of yellow liquid was leaking through the light in the bathroom ceiling. Disgusting trying not to imagine what this could be… staff told us they only work there and to email manager. Good location and breakfast but would not stay here again or recommend it to others