Overall Ratings & Reviews Borgo Il Melone

We were initially uncertain about booking here due to some negative online comments; however, very happy we did! it would be difficult to pristinely maintain the property as it is historic and quite large, so if you’re looking for something with every modern amenity, this is not the stay for you. However, the property is a gorgeous setting and the buildings are quaint and charming. Our room was very spacious - a bit of noise transfer through the bathroom. Pool area is beautiful! Great breakfast with tons of selection. Friendly and helpful staff. Good location to easily access Cortona.

Hotel was ideal for a relaxed stay when visiting for a friends wedding. The pool area was lovely and the hotel very pretty. Main area for feedback was that the air con was not the most powerful so room was warm but not uncomfortable.

Such a beautiful property. Loved it

All around excellence. Great location. Clean and spacious.

Beautiful oasis surrounded by olive groves and Cyprus’s. Great staff in lobby and breakfast service- grazie Filipo and Micheal. Very clean spacious rooms with great shower.

Had an amazing time. Hotel staff was awesome. Went out of their way to make our stay enjoyable. Wish we had stayes longer.

Good price and room comfortable but could have been cleaner. Blanket on bed covered in pet hair We were led to believe Cortona was walkable, it definitely was not. Reception staff poor welcome and uninterested. Disappointing restaurant was closed, so had to travel each evening for dinner. Television did not work.

From the moment you arrive you will fall in love with this place, cozy , well keep and clean , nicely decorated and furnished rooms , and an excellent breakfast, we will come back

This property deserves a 5 star rating, superb staff, Alberto and the front desk staff go beyond their duty to make sure your stay is comfortable and the breakfast is the best, highly recommend this Tuscany Mountain hotel.

Really nice old small village converted to a nice resort.

We’ve stayed there before, but had a car. This time, it said they had rental cars and could assist with taxis. Not true at all! Most of our group had to walk from the train station with luggage and then we walked back into town after we were told there were no rentals or taxis that day or the next. We got lucky at a fiat dealer and we’re able to rent a car. Also, the air conditioning was not reliable in two of the rooms and my son was told it was June and he could open a window (no screens). I always confirm there is air conditioning before booking hotels. I’m not sure if they have new management, but I was disappointed

It was empty. They acted like they had no room for us but we were the only ones there. I felt unsafe and unwelcome. We left before we even got there because we could not get around the area and they did not help us try and get a taxi.

Very nice spot, great location to tour the area.

Definitely recommend a car for visiting the surrounding area and reaching the hotel. The restaurant food was good, although a little pricey for what was served. Pool was wonderful. My comfort double room was very clean, comfortable bed, and very large and clean bathroom. The property was lovely and has many fruit trees! The breakfast was quite good with excellent coffee!

Beautiful, quiet, great dinning on site, free safe parking on site

team from the beginning did not pay the slightest attention to us, being strangely grumpy and unprepared. Breakfast awful…waitress complaining and going out to smoke all the time… one star is better… room was smelling very bad. we called to the reception asking for the manager, who never came to our room…. sorry, 4 stars????? until now i’m waiting for an apology. level 0.

This property is very charming, spacious and well-kept. The staff was so helpful with us and flexible with our needs as they changed. The value was truly incredible.

Very nice place with lovely staff. We had a big room and everything was great.

Large room with great views and good location. Grounds beautiful. Helpful staff. Pool area excellent. Good restaurants close by. Would stay here again. Good base to explore the region.

Lovely place to stay in Tuscany-relaxed by the pool in the sun and enjoy some quiet time between Florence and Rome. Great place!