The good: beautiful hotel, accommodating staff, TnT restaurant and Yaya restaurant were both very good.
The bad: Comal restaurant was disappointing. My wife has celiac and cannot eat gluten. During our three night stay at Chileno Bay, we ate at Comal twice (a dinner and a breakfast) and she food was cross-contaminated with gluten on these two occassions. Disappointing as we were only there three nights and she was sick our entire stay. Not so great when paying the price we paid.