Overall Ratings & Reviews Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport

Place is disgusting

By far the worst place I've ever stayed, all around. I showed up a day late from a delayed flight and they said they couldn't refund me a day since I prepaid. There was no wifi, no shampoo or body wash half of the days. When I asked for a fork, the motel attendant told me to go across the street and get one from the gas station. The beds were terrible as well.

It was our first time in New York. The hotel was super cute. Kinda vintage compared to the ones back home. Over all pretty quiet and everyone was friendly. I would def stay here again.

It’s a motel, I was planning to stay there with my wife for the night, we couldn’t stay there was small, and old.

Was to expensive for what you got. You need new toilet seat and some updating.

Although the building was an old building, the place was updated and immaculately clean

Beds creeked water damage on bottom of sink, wallpaper peeling, mini fridge didn’t work.

Small room at a reasonable price.

Carpet was old and dirty. Room had a sour moldy smell. Property looked like a junkyard without a dog

Unique? That I witnessed this transaction: check-in a 9:55am, check out at noon. Woman concierge said: "Even though our computer does not work, and the motel book says we'll give you the first 5 pages of copies free, and you coudln't even get coffee/tea b/c there is no breakfast, and NONE of our machines work in the dining space, I can't help you print documents for closing on a home because I am busy; very busy." You cannot print documents for me to close on a home? "GO TO STAPLES!" I came back 35 minutes later [checked out early; canceled the next 3 days of stay online] and witnessed the "Pay-by-the-hour" transaction described above. Oh, I see!

Everything was perfect

Everything was good

Toilet needed to be plunged, and left the plunger on the floor, rust on the refrigerator and inside slightly cold, microwave was dirty inside. Lukewarm water, the shower handle was broken. In the morning I discovered Big ants on bed and small ants by the door which wasn’t sealed properly. I left the next morning and demanded my money back. I was staying 5 days. Got a full refund. The manager said”what did you expect” cheap Inn.

The worst place I’ve ever stayed in

Very clean room

I was here for three days and two nights with my two sons and it was very comfortable. We had a non-smoking room with two queen beds. Beds were clean and comfortable. The ac was working great. Tv was a smart tv so all apps (that you have) were accessible. My only issues was the towels. They are very small and when I asked for extra, we only received one extra. I would completely stay here again if the opportunity arises again.

Not fancy but was clean. Staff was pleasant and polite. Easy parking and only 3 miles from the airport. Remember that this is an inexpensive motel, not the Hilton. I would recommend it to anyone on a budget.

Waste of time

Terrible odor of stale smoke and musty. Bed sheets fell apart like wet paper.

Falling wall paper and dirty bathroom. Really needs an overhaul.