Overall Ratings & Reviews The Magnolia Hotel, St Augustine Downtown Historic District, FL

Horrible rugs, very dirty, moldy smell in MY room. Not cleaned at all, someone else's towel left in my room.

Filth and garbage under the bed Place seemed dumpy and decrepit Ac was cold Staff was courteous Don’t look forward to returning Would rather pay more for better quality in the future

Quality of stay was enjoyable for the price. Room service is not available for a short stay.

Its really old, carpets are dirty. No staff after 7pm, so it was just me and two other people staying at the hotel.

Great value- clean- and close to everything

Everything was great but undergoing construction

Nice hotel close to historical downtown. Safe and quiet area. Outdated/older property but still nice

Good!

Hotel was really dirty, musty smelling and rain pouring in window. Carpet dirty and smelled. Will never go back.

We found mold in the room, Breakfast was a disaster, we had to go to the restaurant next door for a decent meal. Would not recommend this place

Great

We had an easy stay at Magnolia. It was relatively close to downtown. The staff was nice and welcoming. The hotel is on the older side of things and can use some refreshing. Nonetheless, it was ok for the price.

The carpet is too old.dirty,dusty and has smoky smell,as well smells rooten,the bathtub was old and crusty.Rooms are not recommended for people with breathing difficulties.Room 214

Hot tub not working. Bathroom and refrigerator dirty. Shower had great hot water. Bed hard. It was a good spot for the night

Not a great place but cheap

Convenient location to a lot of attractions. Very reasonable priced. Clean property. Looks like they recently had a refresh. Rooms were clean and had a very comfortable bed. Breakfast was good. Eggs, sausage, waffle, muffins,bagels, cereal, etc to enjoy. Plus there is a great little mexican restaurant across the road for lunch or dinner.

Dated hotel but roomy snd clean. Stayed 2 nights and never saw housekeeper. Very empty hotel Plesant clerks

This place is a dump. I get the impression they are about to start renovations because the outside was freshly painted. The tables and chairs out by the pool were rusty. Our shower head had exposed drywall. Brown stains on the lampshades. It has potential to be nice once they start renovations, but I highly recommend waiting until they are done.

Very very short of staff. Poorly breakfast There was any soap to take a shower not even to wash hands

TV didn’t work. Rust on lamp shades mold in bathroom. Does not look like pictures they post