Overall Ratings & Reviews Carnegie Hotel

This hotel for me was perfect - one of the most important things for me at a hotel is that the climate control is good. I like a very cool room at night and i was able to control the air and it was great and it worked. I liked that there was a breakfast to get me out the door each morning and not look around or need to go find a breakfast when I was walking 8-10 miles to begin with. and the happy hour was convenient to grab a snack after a long day and before a long night out.

Definitely my new favorite place to stay mid-town. Rooms were so clean and the staff super friendly and they have free coffee and drinks all the time.

Everything was impeccable.

Convenient breakfast. Excellent staff. Amazing room layout and view. A bit of wear (curtain tattered on one side from automatic blind mechanism, some water damage on bathroom molding), but otherwise the room was in great shape and perfect for office work away from home. Also, great mid town location.

Very clean and modern rooms. Rooms are small but enough room. Lots of bureau space. Beautiful bathroom. Excellent staff and location. Right across the street from Carnegie Hall and easy walk to Grand Central. Would definitely come back.

Great view and great location.

Nice clean local hotel. Very small rooms. Great location.

Very efficient rooms and nice bathroom. Comfortable bed. Small but well designed rooms and the location is great.

Rooms are smaller than photos. But that's NYC! Everyone at hotel was friendly and very welcoming. I recommend if you are just looking for clean, quite hotel. If you intend to spend more time in the day in your room this might not be the one for you. Good for sleeping after long day of touring the city. Pillows were very comfortable.

It was a great place to stay, great location

A slight hiccup on water temperature forced a room change, so we didn't get started on the best foot. However, every single staff member went above and beyond to be courteous, professional, helpful, and kind. This included management, front desk, service technicians, and happy hour / breakfast staff. We felt incredibly welcome and taken care of. The rooms are Manhattan standard size (smaller than most US cities), but well laid out and comfortable. Location is just a short walk to Midtown sites.

Everything is very average at this hotel. It was clean and staff was friendly. Breakfast average. It was fine, just not what I expected or hoped for based on the other reviews I read.

This is a very simple hotel, however, the rooms are quite new and very clean and the staff is super responsive. Nothing flashy, but it totally does the trick.

An excellent mid-tier, midtown hotel. Like-new throughout, with friendly and attentive staff. Our superior queen room was compact but thoughtfully designed and met our needs admirably. Breakfast room is small. Pleasant evening wine hour could be improved with a bit more food.

We had a lovely stay! Every staff member was so friendly. Hotel was very clean! We loved our room - the shower was incredible and our bed was super comfortable. It was an easy walk over to the Metropolitan Opera and we really enjoyed the Carnegie diner for dinner. My husband thought the breakfast was really good for an included continental, he loved the omelettes. It was also nice always having coffee, tea, juice and snacks in the lobby. We would definitely stay here again for a Broadway show or another opera. I’d highly recommend here!

Small but mighty! For NYC, very nice hotel. Upgraded rooms have a great view but street noise. Standard rooms are much smaller but no street noise. All is small but very comfortable with extremely helpful employees, especially in helping us with my elderly in-laws and their wheelchair needs.

Best midtown hotel for the money, with proximity to shopping, culture, work, and dining. Beautiful rooms and quiet place to escape to. Excellent staff!

The staff was cheerful, helpful, and knowledgeable!!

Fantastic experience all the around!! Check-in was fabulous. Front desk was very accomodating, professional and friendly. Hotel feels new. Very clean and sleek. Location cannot be beat! Room was very small - but we knew and expected that, but was really, really great. We cannot wait to return.

Cozy and clean hotel in a great location. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The breakfast included a variety of foods and there were snacks each evening.