Overall Ratings & Reviews Magnolia Pointe, BW Signature Collection

Nice place. Would go again, for sure. The outdoor seating area is on the side of the hotel near a busy road, so it was a little noisy, but not too bad. It seemed to share a pool with the neighboring hotel, but space was not a problem.

The best hotel I've ever stayed in. Clean, organized and new

Good comfortable stay got a rude response when I called for clarity on directions. But all was fine when we arrived and I would stay there again.

My only problem was with the check in...most people like myself who travel for work use a company or a contractor company card for everything I mean everything. All hotels need to change the personal card rule for this one reason. Most are not traveling for leisure.

The bed frame was super noisy, breakfast not good it could be improved

I had a king bed but small pillow you might want to get king size pillows

Front desk attendant Keisha was very nice and professional. Urge me to try the breakfast and take advantage of the pool. (Glad I listened, breakfast was delicious.) I will be back when visiting Sarasota.

Close to everything

Great!

Wonderful hotel with coinvent access to Nathan Benderson Park. We were in town for the FSRA Championships 2025 and this hotel is my new favorite for future regattas. We will stay again!

Very clean, staff were great to deal with. Breakfast was great!!

A good property at a reasonable price.

Rooms were great. Didn’t realize you share the pool with the other hotel.

Property nice, outside clean breakfast was great

Very nice hotel handy to the highway. Comfortable bed and great shower. Nice breakfast too! Appreciated your policy of no smoking, no vaping or marajuana use—I get very tired of the horrible smell. Nice to see a hotel enforce that rule with a fine. Appreciated 1 hour late checkout

Nice hotel, staff very friendly and a great hot breakfast

Unfriendly staff, added an extra “eco” fee to total, electricity kept going off and on - obviously didn’t have a generator, room smelled of mildew, the air conditioner wouldn’t cool, breakfast was less than desirable . A very miserable stay.

Convenient, clean, and affordable.

Clean room and facility! Would stay again.

Overall excellent experience there!